As a player, there is no doubt that Anson played like a Hall of Famer. He had a career batting average of .334, won eight RBI titles, and had over 3,000 career hits, a total which is pretty much universally accepted to merit a player automatic election. Pete Rose, with 4,256 lifetime hits (821 more than Anson), is not in the Hall of Fame on account of some illegal betting that he did. Rose bet on ballgames during his time managing the Reds, but he only bet on his own team. This is indeed enough to exclude him from the Hall of Fame, but it doesn't hold a candle compared with what Anson did. The fact that Anson is in the Hall of Fame and that Rose is not is absolutely ludicrous.
My opinion: Cap Anson was a disgrace to baseball, and definitely not a Hall of Famer.
I get what you're saying, but.....
ReplyDeleteThe first to get 3,000 hits. Played for 27 years. A .334 batting average. He probably wouldn't get elected today, but I think he deserves to be in. He had a hand in instituting the color line, but it's not like he was the only one person who made or perpetuated it. And he was a great player.