Showing posts with label hall of fame results. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hall of fame results. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 20, 2026

2026 Hall Of Fame Ballot Results

The BBWAA's annual Hall of Fame voting results have been released. 

Carlos Beltran - 84.2% of the vote 

Andruw Jones - 78.4% 

Chase Utley - 59.1% 

Andy Pettitte - 48.5% 

Felix Hernandez - 46.1% 

Alex Rodriguez - 40.0% 

Manny Ramirez - 38.8% (aged off ballot) 

Bobby Abreu - 30.8% 

Jimmy Rollins - 25.4% 

Cole Hamels - 23.8% 

Dustin Pedroia - 20.7% 

Mark Buehrle - 20.0% 

Omar Vizquel - 18.4% 

David Wright - 14.8% 

Francisco Rodriguez - 11.8% 

Torii Hunter - 8.7% 

Dropoffs From Future Ballots 

Ryan Braun - 3.5% 

Edwin Encarnacion - 1.4% 

Shin-Soo Choo - 0.7% 

Matt Kemp - 0.5% 

Hunter Pence - 0.5% 

Rick Porcello - 0.5% 

Alex Gordon - 0.2% 

Nick Markakis - 0.2% 

Gio Gonzalez, Howie Kendrick, Daniel Murphy - 0% 


After several ballots each, Carlos Beltran and Andruw Jones were elected by the BBWAA this year. While I am pleased with the induction of Jones, a ten-time Gold Glove centerfielder who hit 434 home runs, I frankly do not think Beltran deserves his plaque. Due to his involvement in the Houston Astros' sign-stealing plot in 2017, one of the worst scandals in baseball history and one that cost him a managing job, I do not believe he is worthy of immortality in Cooperstown. However, I realize that his career record is among the greatest of all time, and that it already was before the scandal. Despite him struggling to get into the Hall on his first three ballots, the BBWAA has proven lenient enough to bypass the incident and focus on the many good things he did in his career. While I ultimately disagree with the voters' decision, I must congratulate Beltran for earning their favor. 

With Beltran's election, the door swings wide for a candidate like Dustin Pedroia, who may or may not have been guilty, but was also part of a team that was nailed for illegal sign stealing. After debuting at 11.9% last year, Pedroia climbed over 20% this year and has an outside shot at induction. Although he played his last full season at age 33 and has meager counting statistics, the 2008 MVP was one of the greatest defensive second basemen of all time and maintained a .300 career batting average until his final seven games. Pedroia should be an intriguing candidate in the coming years. 

At 59.1% on his third ballot, Chase Utley is quickly becoming a likely candidate for induction, perhaps even in the next year or two. A six-time all-star and postseason hero for the Phillies, the slugging second baseman has a compelling case for the Hall of Fame. 

After middling on the ballot for six years, Andy Pettitte jumped to 27.9% in 2025 and 48.5% this year, making him a legitimate candidate for induction. While I personally would not vote for him, he is the winner of 256 games (plus 19 more in the postseason) and five World Series rings, making him an attractive candidate to many voters. 

After debuting at 20.6% last year, Felix Hernandez garnered a surprising 46.1% of the vote in 2026, a second-year tally which has historically bidden well for players. While I believe Hernandez's career is short of the Hall's standards (169-136 record, 3.42 ERA in 2,729 2/3 innings), he seems to be gaining the necessary traction that would lead to his induction. 

Similarly, Cole Hamels debuted with 23.8%, slightly higher than Hernandez's first-year total. Although Hamels's career was more consistent and less spectacular than Hernandez's, their career numbers are nearly identical, and given the outcomes of their respective ballots, it seems clear that the BBWAA's criteria for starting pitchers are changing. 

Although still only at 30.8%, Bobby Abreu jumped from 19.5% on last year's ballot, meaning he may still have a shot at a plaque. A consistent star who performed mostly under the radar, Abreu is one of the best players on the current ballot and has been for years. 

Finally, it is time to say goodbye to Manny Ramirez, who was aged off his tenth and final ballot. Despite 555 career home runs, the Hall has once again shown that it will not cave to steroid users. 

Saturday, December 13, 2025

2025 Contemporary Era Hall Of Fame Ballot Results

On December 7, the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee released the results of their 2025 election. 

Jeff Kent - 14 of 16 votes 

Carlos Delgado - 9 votes 

Don Mattingly - 6 votes 

Dale Murphy - 6 votes 

Fernando Valenzuela, Gary Sheffield, Roger Clemens, Barry Bonds - fewer than 5 votes each 

After having been staved off the BBWAA ballot, Jeff Kent has finally made it to Cooperstown. The 2000 MVP and record holder for career home runs among second basemen, he is more than worthy of this honor. 

Read my previous blog post from 2023 in advocacy of his selection: 

Tuesday, January 21, 2025

2025 Hall Of Fame Ballot Results

The BBWAA's annual Hall of Fame voting results are in. 

Ichiro Suzuki - 99.7% of the vote 

CC Sabathia - 86.8% 

Billy Wagner - 82.5% 

Carlos Beltran - 70.3% 

Andruw Jones - 66.2% 

Chase Utley - 39.2% 

Alex Rodriguez - 37.1% 

Manny Ramirez - 34.3% 

Andy Pettitte - 27.9% 

Felix Hernandez - 20.6% 

Bobby Abreu - 19.5% 

Jimmy Rollins - 18.0% 

Omar Vizquel - 17.8% 

Dustin Pedroia - 11.9% 

Mark Buehrle - 11.4% 

Francisco Rodriguez - 10.2% 

David Wright - 8.1% 

Torii Hunter - 5.1% 

Dropoffs From Future Ballots 

Ian Kinsler - 2.5% 

Russell Martin - 2.3% 

Brian McCann - 1.8% 

Troy Tulowitzki - 1.0% 

Curtis Granderson - 0.8% 

Adam Jones - 0.8% 

Carlos Gonzalez - 0.5% 

Hanley Ramirez, Fernando Rodney, and Ben Zobrist - all squat 


Everybody knew that Ichiro would sail in on his first ballot; the only question was whether he would be the BBWAA's second unanimous selection. It turns out that he ended up one vote short. I really wouldn't want to be the guy who didn't vote for him right now... 

I found Sabathia's first-ballot selection a little surprising, but perfectly satisfactory. A six time all-star and 2007 AL Cy Young Award winner, Sabathia is one of only eight pitchers to win 100 or more games with two different teams, a feat he accomplished with the Indians and Yankees. 

At long last, Billy Wagner has made it to the Hall of Fame. In his final year of eligibility, Wagner made an 8.7% jump from last year's ballot and opens the door for a couple active closers (Kimbrel and Jansen) to make a run at the Hall in a few years. 

In only his second year on the ballot, Chase Utley received almost 40% of the vote (a 10.4% increase from last year), giving the impression that he will likely be inducted before his term expires. Hopefully that will be the case. 

Interestingly, Andy Pettitte more than doubled his vote tally from last year, finishing at 27.9% as opposed to 13.5% last year. This is rather unusual for a seventh year candidate, but I don't think he'll be inducted by the BBWAA (which is fine with me). 

Rather surprisingly, Felix Hernandez received 20.6% of the vote on his first ballot, which is a significant number. A popular player and truly elite pitcher for a while (he won the AL Cy Young Award in 2010 and finished second in two other seasons), King Felix was finished at 33 and seems to lack the traditional Hall of Fame pitching stats (169-136 record, 3.42 ERA). He may yet surprise me and end up in Cooperstown someday. 

I am also a little surprised that Pedroia debuted with 11.9% while Kinsler was booted off with 2.5% of the vote. I figured their careers were very similar and would be treated similarly by the voters, but I guess I was wrong. 

And once again, I must complain about Carlos Beltran's progress on the ballot. He received over 70% of the vote this time so he will almost certainly be inducted next year, but I still maintain that he should not. 

Congratulations to the Hall's three new inductees, who will be officially inducted into the Hall of Fame in July. 

Sunday, December 8, 2024

Classic Baseball Era Ballot Results

    The Classic Baseball Era Ballot results were announced today, with two new members earning their plaques. 

Although I advocated his case back in 2021, Dave Parker (who was included on 14 of 16 ballots) isn't an ideal Hall of Famer. While he was elite for a few years early in his career, Parker couldn't sustain that level of production for long, and ended up compiling his career totals as a run of the mill outfielder and DH who stuck around for a long time. 

Dick Allen (13 of 16 ballots), however, was a good pick for the Hall. After missing out by a single vote on each of his last two ballots, he finally got in this year, although he didn't live to see the honor. Allen was one of the greatest hitters of his generation, slashing .292 / .378 / .534 (156 OPS+) with 351 home runs in 1,749 games. 

Well, this wasn't really what I wanted to see, as both Ken Boyer and Luis Tiant missed out again while Parker is immortalized forever. Oh well. 

Tuesday, January 23, 2024

2024 Hall Of Fame Ballot Results

The BBWAA's annual Hall of Fame voting results are in. 

Adrian Beltre - 95.1% of the vote 

Todd Helton - 79.7% 

Joe Mauer - 76.1% 

Billy Wagner - 73.8% 

Gary Sheffield - 63.9% 

Andruw Jones - 61.6% 

Carlos Beltran - 57.1% 

Alex Rodriguez - 34.8% 

Manny Ramirez - 32.5% 

Chase Utley - 28.8% 

Omar Vizquel - 17.7% 

Bobby Abreu and Jimmy Rollins - 14.8% 

Andy Pettitte - 13.5% 

Mark Buehrle - 8.3% 

Francisco Rodriguez - 7.8% 

Torii Hunter - 7.3% 

David Wright - 6.2% 

Dropoffs From Future Ballots 

Jose Bautista and Victor Martinez - 1.6% 

Bartolo Colon - 1.3% 

Matt Holliday - 1.0% 

Adrian Gonzalez - 0.8% 

Brandon Phillips - 0.3% 

Jose Reyes and James Shields - both squat 


Everybody saw Beltre's first ballot induction coming. The owner of 3,166 hits, 477 home runs, and five Gold Gloves, he is undoubtedly one of the greatest third basemen of all time. 

I knew that Helton was going to get in this year. As I have mentioned before, I have some reservations about his case, but I don't want to spoil his big day by going through them again. 

I am glad that Mauer got in. I was a little nervous that the voters would punish him for his five year stint as a first baseman, but as it stands he is one of the greatest catchers of all time and a first ballot Hall of Famer. 

Due to the shortened 10 year window that players have on the ballot, Gary Sheffield has fallen off with 63.9% of the vote. If the 15 year standard were still in place, he'd have a good chance to get in, but instead he is on the outside looking in. One can only hope that a Contemporary Era committee will vote him in. 

After his 5.7% jump from last year (as opposed to a 17.1% leap the year before), I am biting my nails about Wagner, who sits on 73.8% heading into his final ballot. Unquestionably one of the finest closers in history, his record includes 422 saves, a 2.31 ERA, and 1,196 strikeouts, better than most enshrined closers. I hope he makes it next year. 

Obviously, I am a little annoyed with Beltran's 10.6% increase, but I saw it coming. While I would never vote him into Cooperstown after his involvement in the Astros' cheating scandal, it seems like most of the voters disagree with me. 

Since the release of this ballot, I've had a change of mind about several players on it. After years of clamoring for Omar Vizquel's induction, I think it might be time to throw in the towel - he keeps slipping in the voting, and on reviewing his numbers I guess I could go either way on him. Likewise, I don't see a need to vote for Jimmy Rollins or David Wright, who I previously expressed a little bit of interest in. On the other hand, Andruw Jones is starting to grow on me - despite a brutal decline after age 30, I'm beginning to like his peak. He hit 434 homers and could conceivably challenge Willie Mays as the best defensive centerfielder in history. Sounds like a Hall of Famer to me. Utley's 28.8% debut is a good sign, and I hope this underrated star can keep climbing and eventually get his plaque. Near the bottom of the ballot languishes Bobby Abreu, a legitimate Hall of Fame candidate who just doesn't pass the "feel test" for the majority of voters. While he rarely led his league in major offensive categories, he was always among the league leaders in offense, and he accrued much of his value through less flashy means, such as doubles and walks. I hope the voters realize his true talent and start checking his name. I am also a little discouraged by K-Rod's 3% drop from last year - another elite closer with even more saves than Wagner (437), he needs to start moving in the other direction. Finally, Torii Hunter continues to linger near the bottom of the ballot. A very talented player, I would love to see him in Cooperstown, but I'd be fine if he didn't make it. 7.3% just doesn't seem like an accurate representation of his career. 

Congratulations to the Hall's three new inductees, who will be officially inducted along with Jim Leyland on July 21. 

Sunday, December 3, 2023

2024 Contemporary Era Hall Of Fame Ballot Results

The results of the 2024 Contemporary Era Hall of Fame ballot are in. 

Jim Leyland - 15 of 16 votes (.938) 

Lou Piniella - 11 votes (.688) 

Bill White - 10 votes (.625) 

Cito Gaston, Davey Johnson, Joe West, Ed Montague, Hank Peters - fewer than 5 votes each 


Aw man... another unworthy Hall of Fame manager. Jim Leyland achieved moderate success as a manager, but the Hall has way too many managers already, and we didn't need another one with a .506 winning percentage. At any rate, I would have really liked to see Bill White get in, and I'd want to see Joe West eventually get in, but that's just the way it goes. 

Thursday, January 26, 2023

2023 Hall of Fame Ballot Results

The BBWAA's annual Hall of Fame voting results are in. 

Scott Rolen - .763 of the vote 

Todd Helton - .722 

Billy Wagner - .681 

Andruw Jones - .581 

Gary Sheffield - .550 

Carlos Beltran and Jeff Kent - .465 

Alex Rodriguez - .357 

Manny Ramirez - .332 

Omar Vizquel - .195 

Andy Pettitte - .170 

Bobby Abreu - .154 

Jimmy Rollins - .129 

Mark Buehrle and Francisco (Frankie) Rodriguez - .108 

Torii Hunter - .069 

Dropoffs From Future Ballots 

Bronson Arroyo, R.A. Dickey, John Lackey, Mike Napoli, Huston Street - .003 

Matt Cain, Jacoby Ellsbury, Andre Ethier, J.J. Hardy, Jhonny Peralta, Jered Weaver, Jayson Werth - nothing 


Obviously, my biggest takeaway is Scott Rolen, who made it to Cooperstown on his sixth ballot. I'm glad he made it, I knew he deserved it, and I'm impressed by his 13.1% jump in the voting since last year. 

I am also pleased by Gary Sheffield's 14.6% jump from last year. At 55% on his ninth ballot, one hopes that he'll have a chance to make it next year. 

The fact that Carlos Beltran garnered 46.5% of votes on his debut ballot is simply astounding. He should definitely make it to Cooperstown, maybe as early as next year. Personally I can't condone him being in the Hall of Fame, considering his role in the Astros' sign stealing scandal, which cost him a managing job in 2020. 

I am disappointed, however, at Omar Vizquel receiving only 19.5% of the vote. On his sixth ballot, it's a 4.4% drop from last year, so things aren't boding well for him. I hope he makes it, but the 11-time Gold Glover will probably end up on this blog at some point. 

The Hall of Fame made a mistake in omitting Jeff Kent. The 2000 NL MVP, Kent is the all time leader in home runs by a second baseman (377). His other counting stats, too, are quite impressive: 1,320 runs scored, 2,461 hits, 560 doubles, 1,518 RBI's. His slash line was .290/.356/.500, making him one of only two second basemen (min. 7,000 PA) with a slugging percentage of at least .500. The other? Rogers Hornsby, the Rajah. I could go on and on. But the Veterans Committee should pick him. 

I am also surprised that Todd Helton and Andruw Jones did so well with the BBWAA. Helton's home-road splits are pretty significant, to say the least. I'm not sure if he belongs, but he'll probably make it next year. I definitely have my doubts about Jones. He was a very good player, a ten time Gold Glover with 434 home runs (including a 51 homer season in 2005), but he was pretty much done at 30. He hung around ineffectively until he was 35, batting .214 across his final six seasons. His overall batting average was .254, and he fell short of 2,000 hits (he has 1,933). I'd be extremely skeptical about his election. 

Monday, December 5, 2022

2023 Contemporary Hall of Fame Ballot Results

The results for the 2023 Contemporary Hall of Fame Ballot are in. 


Fred McGriff - 16 of 16 ballots (1.000) 

Don Mattingly - 8 votes (.500) 

Curt Schilling - 7 votes (.438) 

Dale Murphy - 6 votes (.375) 

Belle, Bonds, Palmeiro, Clemens - fewer than 4 votes each 


In my opinion, Fred McGriff was probably the best player outside of the Hall of Fame until yesterday. McGriff had eight seasons with over 100 RBI's (1,550 career) and ten 30 homer seasons (493 career). 

Once again, Curt Schilling was passed over in the voting. This is no surprise, considering that he asked to be removed from his last BBWAA ballot, and doesn't want to be honored by an establishment as political and nasty as the Hall of Fame. Schilling is obviously one of the greatest pitchers who ever lived, and I think he can live with that. 

The bottom four on the list demonstrate one obvious truth - if you can't play it straight, you won't make the Hall of Fame. This is a shame for Bonds and Clemens, who could have been Hall of Famers if they'd never taken the stuff. As "Crime Dog" Fred McGriff might say, crime doesn't pay! 

As for the other two players on this list, Mattingly and Murphy, I don't really care if they make it or not. They were both very good players, and I wrote posts about them for this blog, but they're not sure-fire Hall of Famers. They may make it sometime in the future on account of their popularity. 

Wednesday, January 26, 2022

2022 Hall of Fame Ballot Results

The BBWAA has voted on this year's Hall of Fame ballot, and the results have been made available to the public. 

David Ortiz - .779 of the vote 

Barry Bonds - .660 

Roger Clemens - .652

Scott Rolen - .632 

Curt Schilling - .586 

Todd Helton - .520 

Billy Wagner - .510 

Andruw Jones - .411 

Gary Sheffield - .406 

Alex Rodriguez - .343 

Jeff Kent - .327 

Manny Ramirez - .289 

Omar Vizquel - .239 

Sammy Sosa - .185 

Andy Pettitte - .107 

Jimmy Rollins - .094 

Bobby Abreu - .086 

Mark Buehrle - .058 

Torii Hunter - .053 

Dropoffs from future ballots 

Joe Nathan - .043 

Tim Hudson - .030 

Tim Lincecum - .023 

Ryan Howard - .020 

Mark Teixeira - .015 

Justin Morneau - .013 

Jonathan Papelbon - .013 

Prince Fielder - .005 

A.J. Pierzynski - .005 

Carl Crawford and Jake Peavy - both squat 

    The Hall of Fame made its worst decision in history in the exclusion of Curt Schilling, an obvious first ballot Hall of Famer. Nobody in the universe believes that Schilling's career doesn't merit induction. He has been a victim of the cancel culture, as he is an outspoken conservative. 
    I have decided that I no longer care who is in the Hall of Fame and who is not. I will still write for this blog and for my book (including future articles on Joe Nathan, Tim Hudson, Jonathan Papelbon, and A.J. Pierzynski), but since I have a good understanding of who should be in and who shouldn't, it doesn't really matter to me. Everyone has his own personal Hall of Fame, and I am simply sharing who could be in mine. I never really looked at the Hall of Fame as a plausible end in itself, since the Hall of Fame over the years has done a pretty awful job. Now that they've gotten political and nasty, I cease to care about who is in the actual shrine at Cooperstown, since the people who voted them there are obviously less qualified to vote than I am, for example. 
    Congratulations, Big Papi, for your first ballot entry. And I am more open to forgive you, BBWAA, since you opened the door for Scott Rolen's induction, shut it on Bonds and Clemens, and will do the same to A-Rod in the future. 

Tuesday, January 26, 2021

2021 Hall Of Fame Ballot Results

Nope. Nobody made it. 

Curt Schilling, 71.1% 

Barry Bonds, 61.8% 

Roger Clemens, 61.6% 

Scott Rolen, 52.9% 

Omar Vizquel, 49.1% 

Billy Wagner, 46.4% 

Todd Helton, 44.9% 

Gary Sheffield, 40.6% 

Andruw Jones, 33.9% 

Jeff Kent, 32.4% 

Manny Ramirez, 28.2% 

Sammy Sosa, 17.0% 

Andy Pettitte, 13.7% 

Mark Buehrle, 11.0% 

Torii Hunter, 9.5% 

Bobby Abreu, 8.7% 

Tim Hudson, 5.2% 

Aramis Ramirez, 1.0% 

LaTroy Hawkins, 0.5% 

Barry Zito, 0.2% 

Michael Cuddyer, Nick Swisher, A.J. Burnett, Dan Haren, Shane Victorino, all nothin' 

Talk about absurdity. Who would vote for Bonds but not Clemens, Sosa, or Manny Ramirez? You are a yes or a no on the steroid issue, and any yes'es who know a thing about the Hall of Fame would think that all of them are worthy. I am personally a strong no, and wouldn't have voted for any of them. It's all or nothing. Biggest disappointment: Aramis Ramirez at 1.0% . He was worthy, and got 1/75 of his due today. And LaTroy Hawkins? He got multiple votes, but had a 4.31 career ERA and 127 saves. What on Earth?