Showing posts with label 2023 Hall of Fame Ballot. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2023 Hall of Fame Ballot. Show all posts

Thursday, January 26, 2023

2023 Hall of Fame Ballot Results

The BBWAA's annual Hall of Fame voting results are in. 

Scott Rolen - .763 of the vote 

Todd Helton - .722 

Billy Wagner - .681 

Andruw Jones - .581 

Gary Sheffield - .550 

Carlos Beltran and Jeff Kent - .465 

Alex Rodriguez - .357 

Manny Ramirez - .332 

Omar Vizquel - .195 

Andy Pettitte - .170 

Bobby Abreu - .154 

Jimmy Rollins - .129 

Mark Buehrle and Francisco (Frankie) Rodriguez - .108 

Torii Hunter - .069 

Dropoffs From Future Ballots 

Bronson Arroyo, R.A. Dickey, John Lackey, Mike Napoli, Huston Street - .003 

Matt Cain, Jacoby Ellsbury, Andre Ethier, J.J. Hardy, Jhonny Peralta, Jered Weaver, Jayson Werth - nothing 


Obviously, my biggest takeaway is Scott Rolen, who made it to Cooperstown on his sixth ballot. I'm glad he made it, I knew he deserved it, and I'm impressed by his 13.1% jump in the voting since last year. 

I am also pleased by Gary Sheffield's 14.6% jump from last year. At 55% on his ninth ballot, one hopes that he'll have a chance to make it next year. 

The fact that Carlos Beltran garnered 46.5% of votes on his debut ballot is simply astounding. He should definitely make it to Cooperstown, maybe as early as next year. Personally I can't condone him being in the Hall of Fame, considering his role in the Astros' sign stealing scandal, which cost him a managing job in 2020. 

I am disappointed, however, at Omar Vizquel receiving only 19.5% of the vote. On his sixth ballot, it's a 4.4% drop from last year, so things aren't boding well for him. I hope he makes it, but the 11-time Gold Glover will probably end up on this blog at some point. 

The Hall of Fame made a mistake in omitting Jeff Kent. The 2000 NL MVP, Kent is the all time leader in home runs by a second baseman (377). His other counting stats, too, are quite impressive: 1,320 runs scored, 2,461 hits, 560 doubles, 1,518 RBI's. His slash line was .290/.356/.500, making him one of only two second basemen (min. 7,000 PA) with a slugging percentage of at least .500. The other? Rogers Hornsby, the Rajah. I could go on and on. But the Veterans Committee should pick him. 

I am also surprised that Todd Helton and Andruw Jones did so well with the BBWAA. Helton's home-road splits are pretty significant, to say the least. I'm not sure if he belongs, but he'll probably make it next year. I definitely have my doubts about Jones. He was a very good player, a ten time Gold Glover with 434 home runs (including a 51 homer season in 2005), but he was pretty much done at 30. He hung around ineffectively until he was 35, batting .214 across his final six seasons. His overall batting average was .254, and he fell short of 2,000 hits (he has 1,933). I'd be extremely skeptical about his election. 

Monday, December 5, 2022

2023 Contemporary Hall of Fame Ballot Results

The results for the 2023 Contemporary Hall of Fame Ballot are in. 


Fred McGriff - 16 of 16 ballots (1.000) 

Don Mattingly - 8 votes (.500) 

Curt Schilling - 7 votes (.438) 

Dale Murphy - 6 votes (.375) 

Belle, Bonds, Palmeiro, Clemens - fewer than 4 votes each 


In my opinion, Fred McGriff was probably the best player outside of the Hall of Fame until yesterday. McGriff had eight seasons with over 100 RBI's (1,550 career) and ten 30 homer seasons (493 career). 

Once again, Curt Schilling was passed over in the voting. This is no surprise, considering that he asked to be removed from his last BBWAA ballot, and doesn't want to be honored by an establishment as political and nasty as the Hall of Fame. Schilling is obviously one of the greatest pitchers who ever lived, and I think he can live with that. 

The bottom four on the list demonstrate one obvious truth - if you can't play it straight, you won't make the Hall of Fame. This is a shame for Bonds and Clemens, who could have been Hall of Famers if they'd never taken the stuff. As "Crime Dog" Fred McGriff might say, crime doesn't pay! 

As for the other two players on this list, Mattingly and Murphy, I don't really care if they make it or not. They were both very good players, and I wrote posts about them for this blog, but they're not sure-fire Hall of Famers. They may make it sometime in the future on account of their popularity. 

Tuesday, November 22, 2022

2023 Hall of Fame Ballot

2023 Hall of Fame Ballot 


    The following players are on the BBWAA Hall of Fame ballot for 2023. After I tell you who they are, I will tell you who I would vote for if given the chance. The new names are mentioned first, and then those who are returning from last year's ballot.


-Bronson Arroyo

 

-Carlos Beltran 

 

-Matt Cain 

 

-R.A. Dickey 

 

-Jacoby Ellsbury 

 

-Andre Ethier 

 

-J.J. Hardy 

 

-John Lackey 

 

-Mike Napoli 

 

-Jhonny Peralta 

 

-Francisco (Frankie) Rodriguez 

 

-Huston Street 

 

-Jered Weaver 

 

-Jayson Werth 

 

-Jeff Kent (10th year on the ballot) 

 

-Gary Sheffield (9th) 

 

-Billy Wagner (8th) 

 

-Scott Rolen (6th) 

 

-Andruw Jones (6th) 

 

-Manny Ramirez (6th) 

 

-Omar Vizquel (6th) 

 

-Todd Helton (5th) 

 

-Andy Pettitte (5th) 

 

-Bobby Abreu (4th) 

 

-Mark Buehrle (3rd) 

 

-Torii Hunter (3rd) 

 

-Alex Rodriguez (2nd) 

 

-Jimmy Rollins (2nd) 

 

 

Each Hall of Fame voter can choose up to ten candidates who they believe to be Hall of Fame worthy. I personally would choose Bobby Abreu, Torii Hunter, Jeff Kent, Francisco Rodriguez, Scott Rolen, Jimmy Rollins, Gary Sheffield, Omar Vizquel, and Billy Wagner. 


Abreu was a fine combination of consistency (.291 lifetime batting average), power (288 home runs), and speed (400 stolen bases). The two time all-star also collected 1,476 walks and was a Gold Glove award winner in the outfield in 2005.

 

Hunter was a nine time Gold Glove award winner in the outfield, a five time all-star, and a .277 lifetime hitter. As one of the greatest all around talents in all of baseball during his heyday, he collected 2,452 hits, including 353 homers and 498 doubles. 


Kent is the all time leader in home runs for a second baseman, totaling 377 for his career. The five time all-star was a .290 career hitter with 1,518 RBI’s and 2,461 hits across seventeen seasons, winning four Silver Slugger awards and the 2000 NL MVP Award. 

 

Francisco Rodriguez (K-Rod) was one of the great closers of all time. In 16 seasons, Rodriguez compiled 52 wins and 437 saves, the latter figure the fourth most of all time, and holds the single season save record with 62 in 2008. An asset to the Angels’ World Series victory as a rookie in 2002, K-Rod averaged 10.5 strikeouts per nine innings for his career. 

Rolen was an eight time Gold Glove award winner at third base and the 1997 NL Rookie of the Year. A seven time all-star, he provided power (316 homers) and consistency (.281 lifetime batting mark) with stellar baserunning skills. 


Jimmy Rollins won four Gold Gloves at shortstop, but was better known for his offense. In 17 Big League seasons, Rollins batted .264 with 231 homers, 115 triples, 470 stolen bases, and 1,421 runs scored. He was the NL MVP in 2007, when he batted .296 with 20 triples and scored 139 runs. 


Sheffield has to his credit 509 home runs, 2,689 hits, 1,676 RBI’s, five Silver Slugger awards, a Batting Title, a 1997 World Series ring, and nine all-star selections - easily Hall of Fame caliber numbers. He admitted in court that he used steroids for a short time, but that he didn’t know what they were at the time, as they were given to him by another player. He also said that he was really upset about the whole deal and that it didn’t help his career at all. His numbers don’t show it, so Sheff gets my vote. 


Vizquel was an eleven time Gold Glove award winner at shortstop and a three time all-star. He holds the career record for the highest fielding percentage at short, a remarkable seven points above Ozzie Smith's (despite playing in Jacobs field for many years, which had artificial turf). Along with his nearly 3,000 career hits, Vizquel scored 1,445 runs, hit 456 doubles, stole 404 bases, and collected 256 sacrifice bunts, leading his league in sacrifices four times. 


Wagner ranks sixth in baseball history with 422 saves. He also had a 2.31 ERA and a 47-40 record in 853 games. The seven time all-star struck out an average of 11.9 batters per nine innings across his 16 MLB seasons. 

 

   A couple other names on this list could be okay Hall of Famers. Todd Helton, despite the Coors field bias, could have been a Hall of Famer in any other stadium. Some people think he’s a no-brainer and are shocked that he’s not already inducted (he’ll probably make it eventually; he finished at 52.0% last year). If someone wanted to argue Huston Street’s case, I’d be inclined to listen, as he was truly a fine closer. Andruw Jones, although I didn't vote for him, seems to be gaining momentum with the BBWAA, which is fine considering he hit 434 homers. And although they’re not Hall of Famers, there are a few players on this list who are truly interesting. Mark Buehrle and Matt Cain threw perfect games; Ellsbury holds numerous hit by pitch records; Lackey was an ace for the Angels; Dickey was a knuckleballer who took Cy Young honors in 2012; and Weaver threw a no-hitter on May 2, 2012, a game that I attended.

Monday, November 14, 2022

2023 Contemporary Hall of Fame Ballot

    On December 4, the Hall of Fame will vote on eight former players as the Contemporary Hall of Fame ballot for 2023. In alphabetical order, those eight players are 

Albert Belle 

Barry Bonds 

Roger Clemens 

Don Mattingly 

Fred McGriff 

Dale Murphy 

Rafael Palmeiro 

Curt Schilling 

I've written about most of these players before, so this will be relatively straightforward. McGriff and Schilling are the Hall's two worst omissions, in my opinion, and I'd expect them to go in (although Schilling was left out for entirely different reasons and dropped off the ballot this year; see my posts on the 2022 Hall of Fame ballot). Obviously I'd leave out Bonds, Clemens, and Palmeiro, but the other three are a little tricky. Belle may or may not have corked his bat, but if all allegations are false I'd probably vote for him. I wrote posts about Murphy (https://thecooperstownadvocate.blogspot.com/2021/04/why-i-think-dale-murphy-should-be-in.html) and Mattingly (https://thecooperstownadvocate.blogspot.com/2020/11/why-i-think-don-mattingly-should-be-in.html), but I'm not sure whether they positively belong. If I had the choice, I'd probably vote for Schilling, McGriff, Murphy, and perhaps Belle. What about you?